Many shipments from China move by more than one mode: a truck to the port, a container across the ocean, and another truck or rail leg to the final consignee. When the goods arrive damaged, the shipper often faces a more difficult dispute than a single-mode shipment. Who answers for the loss — the booking agent, the ocean carrier, or the local inland carrier? And how much can you actually recover?
Chinese law treats these arrangements through a dedicated set of rules on multimodal transport contracts. This article explains the framework in plain terms, based on the current Maritime Code of the People's Republic of China.
I. What Is a Multimodal Transport Contract Under Chinese Law?
Under Article 102 of the Maritime Code, a multimodal transport contract is one under which a multimodal transport operator (MTO) — using two or more different modes of transport, at least one of which is maritime — undertakes to carry the goods from the place of receipt to the place of destination and deliver them to the consignee, in return for through freight.
The MTO is the party who contracts with the shipper, either in person or through another person acting on its behalf. It does not matter that the MTO later subcontracted part of the journey to someone else.
Two points follow:
- The MTO is liable for the whole carriage. Under Articles 103 and 104, the operator's responsibility runs from receipt of the goods to delivery, and the operator remains responsible for the entire transport. An internal contract between the MTO and a segment carrier may allocate responsibilities between them, but it does not reduce the MTO's liability to the shipper.
- Your counterparty is the MTO, not the inland subcontractor. If the MTO arranged the sea leg itself and handed the inland leg to a local carrier, the shipper's claim against the through transport is still directed at the MTO.
II. Where the Damage Occurred Decides Which Rules Apply
A damaged-cargo claim on a multimodal shipment follows one of two tracks.
(A) The damaged leg can be identified
Under Article 105, if the loss or damage occurred on a specific transport leg, the MTO's liability and liability limitation are governed by the law applicable to that mode of transport. Damage during the ocean leg is handled under the Maritime Code rules for carriers; damage during the inland leg is governed by the applicable land transport rules.
This is why locating the damage precisely matters: it determines the substantive standard and the available limits.
(B) The damaged leg cannot be identified
Under Article 106, if the transport leg where the loss or damage occurred cannot be determined, the MTO bears compensation under the carrier liability and liability limitation provisions of the Maritime Code itself. In practice, this is the scenario where the shipper cannot prove whether the damage happened on the water, during transit, or on the final inland leg.
III. How Much Can You Recover? The Statutory Liability Limit
(A) The default measure: actual value
Article 55 sets the baseline measure. Compensation for lost goods is based on their actual value; compensation for damaged goods is based on the difference in value before and after the damage, or on the repair cost. Actual value is calculated as the value of the goods at the time of shipment plus insurance and freight, less expenses saved or avoided as a result of the loss or damage.
(B) The carrier's unit liability limit
Where the limitation rules apply, Article 56 caps the carrier's liability at the higher of:
- 666.67 Units of Account (special drawing rights) per package or other shipping unit; or
- 2 Units of Account per kilogram of the gross weight of the lost or damaged goods.
For consolidated goods in a container or pallet, the packages enumerated in the transport document count toward the package number; if the document does not enumerate them, the whole consolidated unit is treated as one package.
(C) Two situations in which the unit limit does not apply
Article 56 itself removes the cap in two situations:
- Declared value inserted in the transport document. The shipper declared the nature and value of the goods before shipment, and that declaration was inserted in the bill of lading or other transport document.
- A higher limit agreed in writing. The carrier and the shipper agreed in the contract on an amount of compensation higher than the statutory limitation.
A common misunderstanding is worth correcting: the fact that the carrier knew the general type, quantity, or rough price of the goods is not, by itself, enough to set aside the statutory limit. What matters legally is whether the cargo value was declared and recorded on the transport document, or whether the parties agreed a higher compensation standard in writing.
(D) The limit is also lost for intentional or reckless conduct
Separately, under Article 59, the carrier cannot rely on the Article 56 or Article 57 limitation if the loss, damage, or delayed delivery resulted from the carrier's act or omission done with intent, or recklessly and with knowledge that such loss, damage, or delay would probably result. This is a different path from the declared-value or agreed-limit exceptions above; it concerns the carrier's conduct rather than the paperwork.
IV. An Illustrative Scenario
The following is a simplified, anonymized summary for illustration only; it does not represent a case handled by our firm.
A Shandong-based exporter shipped a consignment of electrical switches to an Indian consignee through a Shanghai-based MTO. The operator contracted for the through journey from Qingdao by sea and then by land in India, and subcontracted the inland leg to a local carrier. On arrival, the consignee found the goods damaged.
The dispute turned on whether the MTO could rely on the statutory unit limitation. The transport agreement had specified the cargo's type, quantity, and price. Whether the operator was confined to the statutory cap depended on whether the declared value had been recorded on the transport document, and whether the agreement had set a higher compensation standard — not simply on the operator having known what the goods were.
For the shipper, the lesson is documentary: an internal description in the negotiation paper is weaker than a value declaration carried onto the bill of lading, or an express written clause on the compensation basis.
V. Practical Steps for Foreign Shippers
- Identify the MTO before booking. Confirm the legal name of the party signing the through transport contract, and keep its inland subcontractor list on file. The subcontractor is not automatically your contractual counterparty.
- Declare cargo nature and value before shipment. Make sure the description and value appear on the bill of lading or multimodal transport document. A value that exists only in your proforma invoice may not defeat the carrier's limit.
- Agree the compensation basis in writing. If full-value recovery matters to you, write an express clause that compensation is assessed on the actual value of the goods, or that a higher limitation than the statutory unit cap applies.
- Preserve leg-specific evidence on arrival. Conduct a joint inspection with the carrier or arrange an independent survey promptly. Take dated photographs, record packaging and container condition, and retain the booking note, transport document, transshipment records, and survey report. The ability to identify which leg the damage occurred on determines which set of rules applies.
- Assemble the claim package early. Contract, proforma invoice, bank records, transport documents, inspection report, and correspondence should be organized before any formal demand, so that both the liability question and the quantum question can be addressed on the record.
This article provides general educational information only and does not constitute legal advice. Transport outcomes depend on the contract wording, the transport documents, the evidence preserved, and the applicable law. For a specific shipment or claim, consult a licensed attorney.
Maritime Code of the People's Republic of China, Articles 55, 56, 57, 59, 102, 103, 104, 105, 106. Statutory provisions may be amended; the text above reflects the current version at the time of writing.
